The Bertie Park Consultation: What will they ask us?

The Bertie Park “Consultation” is this Autumn.

Imagine you want a child to sleep before the baby sitter arrives. Don’t ask if they want to go to bed. The answer will be no. Ask a different question instead like: “Which bed-time story shall I read?” This is more likely to get them to do what you want.

What has this got to do with the Bertie consultation?

The council won’t ask us if they can build on our recreation ground. The answer will be no. Instead, they will ask how they can turn the waste-land behind Wytham Street into a wonderful community space.

Police and parents say that the waste-land is not safe for unaccompanied children. Parents with kids playing on Bertie cannot even see it! How could it be a replacement for the green space/buffer zone?

View of Bertie Park from the Waste Land

Click here for what happened in the last “consultation”. Click here for a quick summary of the other issues.

Save Bertie Park Campaign in conversation with OCC

This beautiful heart appeared on Bertie Park a couple of weeks ago

Our address to council on Monday 18th (read here) received good applause from councillors. In reply, Alex Hollingworth said what he always says (read here). He also said that the consultation will take place this autumn.

Once again, Bertie Park featured in the Labour newsletter. Naomi Waite said:

As ever, I’m committed to supporting our community spaces …. Our community will face some difficult issues over the coming years. The plans to build social housing next to the playground and multi-games area in Bertie Park will be brought forward for consultation in the coming months.

As Bertie park is the only community space at the southern end of the ward. It is clear which part of the Hinksey Park ward will “face some difficult issues”!

Naomi has offered to find out why they chose to build on Bertie Park in the first place, and which other recreation grounds were considered.

She said that she wasn’t sure what she thought about buffer zones (i.e. the green space on our recreation ground), but said that she would find out how many of the council’s playgrounds have buffer zones.

A Place to Play

Oxford desperately needs homes. Cllr Hollingsworth has told us:

It’s my view and the view of this Council that we – the current generation fortunate enough to live in this wonderful city – should do our best to make sure that our children both have places to play in their childhood AND the hope of being able to live in Oxford when they grow up and want to have children of their own.

Cllr Alex Hollingsworth

What do the council mean by “places to play”? The sacrifice that they are asking our children to make would mean a recreation ground without a blade of grass and a nature trail that neither police or local parents think is safe for unaccompanied children.

OCC say that they do not intend to provide homes for families within the city centre because the land is too expensive. If they are going to export their housing to this ward, we also need a safe place for our children to run and shout and play.

The election was not a referendum on Bertie Park

Bertie Park was mentioned in some Labour leaflets, but it was not on the ballot paper.

Some of our campaign members would never vote anything but Labour. The Labour Party has been in power in Oxford for so long that it can now govern by decree. Oxford City Council members refuse to meet with us, to keep us updated or engage with our arguments. If something is mentioned in a leaflet, candidates are obliged to support it. But it doesn’t mean that it is right. Or that it is legal.

What does Labour say about Bertie Park?

What does this really mean? It means that councillors have finally realised that they can’t just build on the playground and multi-use games area. The local plan says that “the existing Bertie Place recreation ground, including a replacement Multi-use Games Area” should be re-provided.

What does this really mean? It means that Naomi and Marie are committed to building on the buffer zone around the playground and the multi-use games area. The MUGA will be underneath somebody’s bedroom window. There will be no grass.

At one end of the ward, there is open air cinema and SOAP. At this end, Naomi is “working with police and cold harbour residents to tackle local anti-social behaviour”. How will building on Bertie Park affect anti-social behaviour?

We need council housing, but we also need recreation grounds. Naomi is a hard-working councillor, but Bertie Park is the heart of our community. Will we let Bertie Park be a casualty in the city council’s drive for a global Oxford? Or do we need an Oxford for the people of Oxford.

OCC Parks and Green Spaces Survey

Oxford city council are carrying out a survey of Parks and Green Spaces. Here is the link. This needs to be completed by March 29th. Completing this for Bertie Park would be really helpful for the campaign, but you can complete this for as many parks as you like. The survey has 9 questions (it has no q 2!):

1 Do you ever visit any parks or open spaces? (Yes/no)

3 The name of the Park, Recreation Ground or Nature Reserve that you would like to comment on.

4 How do you normally travel there in the Summer?

5 How do you normally travel there in the Winter?

6 What do you value most about this park/green space?

7 What is your opinion of the facilities? These are listed (Good/fair/poor/no opinion)

8 We would like to know your top five priorities. The facilities are listed. One is high and five is low.

9 Are there any changes you would like to see in the park/green space?

10 Are there any other comments you would like to make about Oxford City Council parks/green spaces?

OCC sends postcards

Post card delivered by OCC to some of the homes around Bertie Park

After waiting nearly 2 months for them to be designed, agreed and printed, postcards have finally been delivered to the homes closest to Bertie Park. They are a little misleading. Homes won’t be built AT Bertie Park, but ON Bertie Park’s boundary zone. This means that Bertie won’t end up looking anything like this …

It will look more like this …

Postcards haven’t been delivered on the other side of the Abingdon road. A local resident said:

The City Council do not care about this side of Abingdon Road; Cold Harbour. We do not matter. We have no right to comment on the plans to build houses on Bertie Park. Our children and Grandchildren are not entitled to play in the park? We did not receive the letter in 2019 informing us about OCC intending to build 31 houses on Bertie Park and have not received the recent leaflet because OCC know we would oppose the plans. Bertie Park is a haven for us all, there are plenty of places to build houses without taking our Bertie Park, a scaled down version is not acceptable.

Resident of Fox Crescent

For those who didn’t get a post card, here is the reverse side. It explains some of the difficulties. OCC promises to share its designs some time in 2022. We assume that this means after the election?

Why building houses on Bertie Park won’t solve the housing crisis

Cllr Hollingsworth has said that he doesn’t understand how not building homes will solve the housing crisis in Oxford. Imagine that the housing crisis is like a hole in the ground. If Oxford City Housing Ltd builds homes, this should fill the hole. The housing list should become smaller.

Images adapted from “Dynamic Equilibrium”, Fuse Chemistry https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlD_ImYQAgQ

But this doesn’t happen. The housing list has been the same size for at least 20 years. A number of factors help keep the housing list exactly the same size. One problem is that Oxford City council aims to create thousands of new jobs in the city centre (but no homes for families). They hope to attract highly skilled workers who can afford Oxford’s house prices. This puts extra pressure on land and house prices for everyone. Housing eats up a greater proportion of household finances. More people struggle. Even when the council builds social housing, the size of the housing list stays the same.

Images taken from “Dynamic Equilibrium”, Fuse Chemistry https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlD_ImYQAgQ

So. Will building houses on Bertie decrease the size of the housing list? Probably not.